The Tennis Ball Problem: Why Resilience Isn’t Enough for HR Leaders
Subscribe to the Newsletter
HR leaders spend their days helping everyone else perform. Very few spend equal time on their own performance, and it shows. According to Lattice’s 2027 State of People Strategy Report, 58% of U.S. HR professionals considered a career change in 2026, up from 48% the year before. The top reason they gave was feeling undervalued, followed by operating in crisis mode and burnout.
Executive coach Melissa Rider Carson argues that the usual prescription, “be more resilient,” is part of the problem. Melissa brings 30 years of experience in leadership, organizational effectiveness, and people strategy, including 20 years at Accenture and EPAM, and now advises CEOs, founders, and leadership teams. She is also a marathoner and triathlete who knows the difference between bouncing back and going the distance.
In a recent conversation with Recognize CEO Alex Grande, she explained why HR leaders need endurance, not just resilience, and how to build it.
Resilience Is a Tennis Ball
Melissa draws a clear line between the two ideas. Resilience is the ability to bounce back when things go wrong. Endurance is having the foundation in place so that bouncing back is easier, and so you can keep performing day after day.
Her metaphor: resilience is a tennis ball. Bounce it over and over, and eventually it doesn’t come back as high. Eventually it goes flat.
That’s where many HR leaders are today. The load has grown steadily since the pandemic, and technology shifts, global uncertainty, and financial pressure keep adding to it. Bouncing back is necessary, but it isn’t a strategy.
The Three Hats HR Wears

Alex framed HR’s workload as three roles:
- The athlete: leading yourself as an individual contributor
- The coach: leading your team to high performance
- The coach’s coach: developing the other managers in the organization
Most HR professionals are natural givers, Melissa says, so the coach’s coach hat carries the most weight, and the athlete hat, taking care of yourself, gets pushed aside. Her reminder is the oxygen mask on a plane: you can’t lead other leaders well if you can’t show up at your best.
Build the Foundation First
Melissa thinks of every workday as a starting line for a race with no finish. If you have to show up fresh for that every day, the foundation matters more than the sprint. Hers includes:
- Sleep. Mainlining coffee on two hours of sleep works for a while, but it isn’t sustainable.
- Quiet time before the inbox. Even five minutes with your coffee, before checking overnight emails, texts, and Slack, to ask: What’s my intention today? Who do I need to be? How will I reset when things don’t go to plan?
- Weekly reflection. Time on the weekend to rest, but also to plan and ask why you keep reacting to the same problems, so you can fix the cause instead of chasing symptoms.
- Cross-training your mind. Just as runners need strength work and stretching, leaders need time with different people, ideas, and environments. Your best thinking rarely happens after ten straight hours at a laptop.
Her advice for anyone overwhelmed by that list: pick one and make it a steady habit.
Never Decide on an Empty Tank

Melissa sees the biggest organizational risk in leaders making critical decisions while running on empty. On half a tank or less, it’s easy to solve part of the problem instead of the root problem, or to react because someone is irritating you. HR then spends months cleaning up the downstream effects.
Before a big decision, she suggests asking:
- What condition am I in right now?
- Do I really need to decide right now? Most situations aren’t true crises.
- Have I thought through the short-term implications, not just the long-term answer?
Sometimes a ten-minute walk outside is enough to clear your head. Alex compared it to rock climbing: when he’s tired and scared on a route, he lets go, hangs on the rope, and suddenly sees the move he missed.
Protect Your Priorities
In a perfect world, Melissa says, you’d have three or fewer priorities a day and a week. The hard part is defending them. It’s easy for someone to stop by or ping you on Slack and make their urgent request your priority, and HR professionals, in helper mode, tend to say “of course.”
Her fix is one question: “When do you actually need this?” Many requests can wait until Monday, especially when you’re in the middle of a comp analysis or another critical project.
If your to-do list keeps winning, try Recognize’s free AI-powered Eisenhower task manager. Enter your role and a task, and it sorts the task into the urgent/important matrix and flags what should be delegated.
Celebrate the Small Wins

There are always 50 more things on HR’s to-do list, so wins go uncelebrated. Melissa recommends keeping a list of 50 ways to celebrate, from stepping outside for fresh air to opening a bottle of champagne, and using it when something good happens, however small.
The same applies to your team. Recognizing progress is what fuels a long race: “I made it a mile. Only 25 more.” Alex suggested a companion habit: keep a visible list of what makes you happy, and audit regularly whether you’re actually doing those things.
Who Supports HR?
HR is expected to make everyone else feel valued, but who does that for HR? The data suggests support makes a measurable difference. In the UK-based HR Mental Wellbeing Report 2026, 38% of HR professionals said they were considering leaving the profession, rising to 66% among those who felt they received no support at work at all.
Melissa’s advice depends on your situation:
- If you’re a solo HR leader, build an external community of HR peers who will celebrate your wins and understand what they took. That network also matters for your career, and it’s best built before you need it.
- If you’re on an HR team, create community internally: share best practices, talk honestly about what’s hard, and coach each other.
- Either way, get comfortable asking for help. Melissa admits this wasn’t her strength. She felt she should be able to do it all, and she sees that mindset holding many HR leaders back.
The Takeaway
Endurance isn’t about doing more. It’s about building a foundation strong enough that you don’t go flat. Melissa’s closing question for every HR leader: What do you need to say no to so you can say yes to what matters most? Every yes is a no to something else, and “not right now” is often all the no you need.
This recap is based on a live webinar hosted by Recognize featuring Melissa Rider Carson, executive coach and strategic advisor. Watch or read the full conversation HERE, or connect with Melissa at melissaridercarson.com.
If you’re ready to explore how recognition, rewards, surveys, and mobile-first communication can help connect your workforce, connect with the Recognize team.